At times like these there are more important things to think about than cricket, but for England fans Mumbai is not just the venue of terrorist attacks, but the place we're planning to visit soon in order to watch our favourite game. So whilst our thoughts go out to the people of Mumbai and anyone affected by last night's tragic events, my immediate social circle all want to know what I'm planning to do about my impending trip and we expect the phones at Barmy Army towers to go a bit crazy today with similar questions.
And the answer is...we don't know. If the tour goes ahead then you'll probably find most people will take the plunge and visit. All of which begs the bigger question of whether, indeed, the tour should go ahead. Everyone's going to have an opinion on this, so I'm already bracing myself for being told what I'm about to say is nonsense, but here goes.
Evidently safety is paramount and advice needs to be taken both from the Indian authorities and British Government. But there's something nagging at the back of my brain that says we should continue if at all possible. There are three reasons for this: firstly, if we don't tour the terrorists have won. They've disrupted the world yet again. Also, for the people of Mumbai having to deal with the aftermath of these events they could probably do with something to look forward to. While they're going about their daily lives in the city it would be a shame if this was enough to put the rest of the word off visiting.
But the bit that keeps coming back to me is this. I live in London. Three years ago we had terror attacks of our own. Speaking to my friend in Mumbai there is a similar feeling over there right now as there was here on that terrible day in 2005. And where was I two weeks after those attacks? Sat at Lord's watching the first Test between England and Australia. Indeed, London hosted two ODIs and a Test in the two and a half weeks immediately after July 7.
I don't know enough about the situation in Mumbai now to make a decision, but I hope for our Indian friends' sake that we try everything we can to make it happen rather than simply walk away without trying to make it work. At the same time it’s worth remembering: it is only cricket.
Appreciate paul for his pragmatic view.
I think the english team had already lost mentally after losing 5-0 and took the mumbai event as a pretext to cancel the tour..
When an Eng-Aus match can happen in London 2 weeks after the london blast, why cant the cricket series go on.
India is a hugh country w.r.t to other cricket playing countries and visitor need to realise that terror attacks in one region may not always have affect/influence in other parts of the country.
Posted by: Amisha on 11/27/2008
As a Brit I think it would be hypocritical for England to come home, in the same way it was hypocritical for the Australians to stay in England after the London blasts, refuse to go to Pakistan and then play in the IPL despite the blasts then.
For Mumbai to recover from this they should play. Cancelling the tour would give the terrorists what they want - disruption to our daily lives and fear spreading.
Well said Paul.
Posted by: Arthur on 11/27/2008
Suggesting people travel to Bombay at this time is not down to a commercial enterprise like yours but the governments of the countries involved.
Yes, life should go on and we mustn't give in to these types, but you have a commercial interest in the tour going ahead and you should make that clear before dishing out advice.
London was horrific, sure. But here UK and US passport holders have been singled out. That's the difference.
Posted by: bharath on 11/27/2008
Hey.. terrific attitude paul .. and honestly .. i think you should go ..look . its just a game .. terrorists don t care at all as to whether a cricket match takes place or not .. looking at it from another angle .. 100 people have just died ... and we choose to just .. get on with our lives ...but I must say .. once again .. I was really really impressed by your take on the whole thing.. not many people would hold the same view .. but kudos... i do hope your wish comes true and you can watch some good cricket :)
Posted by: Dissing Dave on 11/27/2008
Please explain to me, why the last 2 one dayers are cancelled but the test series in 2 weeks time will go ahead? These terrorists have been shown to be targetting brits and yanks, by the reported witnesses, appreciating that the vast majority of the dead and injured are Indian. Where is the sense of high profile British Sportsmen remaining in India for a further 2 weeks? This to me, therefore, means the touring party are less worried about there safety and more concerned about winning games. No chance in the one dayers - call them off, might be able to win a test - Ok we'll play that! It just does not make sense to me!
If you feel you are in danger come home, if not, play all the games. Ths halfway house is frankly ridiculous!
Posted by: Pratyush on 11/27/2008
Wishful thinking really, I appreciate your concern and thoughts but I personally think, this is just a game and even if my team was involved I would ask them to come back to safety, plain and simple. England should not take any chance and so should India. We all know we can for sure protect a group of people and I'm fairly confident that the Indian Govt can protect the English and the Indian teams but why take the chance ? Its just a game after all. Good thpughts though. Much Appreciated.
Posted by: Hakoon on 11/27/2008
And what are your thoughts on England's commitments to tour Pakistan Paul? Should they be given the same consideration?
And my heartfelt condolonces to all the innocent people who list their lives in this senseless tragedy. I hope the good people of Mumbai recover from this soon
Posted by: Atul Bhogle on 11/27/2008
I understand the whole not letting the terrorists win thing but if I were a Britisher, knowing that American and Britishers were singled out in the attack, I would have been booking the first flight home.
Anyways, thanks for the encouraging thought. Stay safe.
Posted by: EH on 11/27/2008
"...there's something nagging at the back of my brain that says we should continue if at all possible. There are three reasons for this: firstly, if we don't tour the terrorists have won. They've disrupted the world yet again. Also, for the people of Mumbai having to deal with the aftermath of these events they could probably do with something to look forward to. While they're going about their daily lives in the city it would be a shame if this was enough to put the rest of the word off visiting." Where is this attitude when it comes to visiting Pakistan? Yet another evidence of Western hypocrisy. The Brits and the Aussies know that they can get away with snubbing Pakistan, but not their Indian paymaster.
Posted by: Mueid Sikander on 11/27/2008
My heartfelt sympathies for Mumbai people. Being a Pakistani, I know how distressful and painful it is. It is amazing yet not unsurprising to see that England team and Barmy army is braving to stay in India to 'not let terrorist win'. Its just sad that terrorists are given this sweet victory without a second thought.
Posted by: Mueid Sikander on 11/27/2008
My heartfelt sympathies for Mumbai people. Being a Pakistani, I know how distressful and painful it is. It is amazing yet not unsurprising to see that England team and Barmy army is braving to stay in India to 'not let terrorist win'. I wonder if galantry would have come forth if it all happened in Pakistan
Posted by: Nishad on 11/27/2008
Not alone for the solidarity and sympathy to those affected by this dastardly act, as a sporting public let,s not give into these hoodlums to terrorise us out of our lives.
Well said Paul and I share your views on it. But lets leave it to the cricketers individually to decide for themselves to play or not. It requires a calm mind free of fear to play sport at the highest level.
These are hard times and we will come through it.
Posted by: Alex Chandy on 11/27/2008
Old Mallu saying:
Mongaan irunna pattiyude thalayil thengaa veenu.
Translation:
The coconut dropped on the head of the dog that was just waiting to moan.
This is more like "saved by the bell" to use a pugilistic term.
Paul Winslow is the Barmy Army's web and magazine editor, a role that allows him to turn an unhealthy and expensive addiction into something vaguely productive. No-one is quite sure how he's managed to combine a career as a sport, travel and motoring journalist with so much travelling to watch cricket but he's blagged it somehow, although he will remain unfulfilled until 2012 when England tour Bangladesh and he will have seen them play in every Test nation.