cricinfo.com About cricinfoblogs
Blogs home
First Class, first person Blues Brothers Rob's Lobs Tour Diaries Pak Spin Girls Aloud
Beyond The Test World On The Circuit What's New The Surfer It Figures The IPL Buzz

Cricinfo Blogs Home

« When The King refused to budge | Coney and the art of pitch analysis »

The tale of a Windies spinner

Posted by Siddhartha Vaidyanathan on 06/28/2006 in India in West Indies 2006





Rangy Nanan chose a profession that merited little attention in the era of raw pace © Siddhartha Vaidyanathan

"For every fast bowler that played for West Indies between 1976 and 1986, there was a spinner whose ambitions of playing international were finished." Elquemedo Willett would know. One who represented West Indies in five Tests between 1973 and 1975, Willett's career came to a premature halt mainly because of West Indies' focus on pace, pace and nothing but pace. Willett's not complaining; in fact he doffs his hat to the great fast bowlers who made West Indies an invincible force. But maybe it's worth sparing a thought for an entire breed who took up, in Willett's words, a "useless profession".

The list of spinners who played only a handful of games for West Indies, in that era, is endless. Raphick Jumadeen (12 Tests), Inshan Ali (12), Imtiaz Ali (1), Derick Parry (12), Albert Padmore (2), Clyde Butts, Willett, Rangy Nanan

Nanan's case is instructive. A prolific domestic wicket-taker, he got his only chance when West Indies toured Pakistan in 1980-81. He had a good time in the tour games - including snapping up 6 for 48 in an innings against the Governer's XI at Sahiwal – and made his debut on a shirt-front at Faisalabad. On a surface, which Dennis Lillie once termed as a bowler’s "graveyard", he returned impressive match figures of 4 for 91. "It wasn't all about performance," he says reflecting on those times. "We needed to understand that, irrespective of how we did, there was always a chance of not playing in the next game. That was how good the fast bowlers were. It was unfortunate. Had I played fifteen years earlier or fifteen years later, things would have been different."

When he ended his first-class career he was the all-time leading wicket-taker in the Shell Shield, the premier domestic competition. Nanan believes that the ill-effects of West Indies' all-pace policy is being felt now. "You don't see too many good spinners in the Caribbean today because the earlier generation wasn't motivated enough. Not too many took up spin in the '80s and '90s because they thought they would not get a chance."

The meeting with Nanan reminded me of an encounter I'd had with Rajinder Goel a few months back. Goel's path was at least blocked by other spinners. In Nanan's case there was just no hope. He chose a profession that merited little attention in the land.

Contributors

Siddhartha Vaidyanathan
Andrew McGlashan
Paul Coupar
John Stern
Dileep_Premachandran
Anand Vasu
George Binoy
Andrew Miller
Will Luke
Charlotte Edwards
Sidharth Monga
S Rajesh
Kumar Sangakkara
Edward Craig
Nagraj Gollapudi
Jenny Thompson
Isobel Joyce
Urooj Mumtaz
Cri-Zelda Brits
Lawrence Booth
Cricinfo

Categories
2007 World Cup Champions Trophy DLF Cup England Women in India England in Australia, 2006-07 England in India, 2005-06 England in New Zealand 2007-08 England in Sri Lanka, 2007-08 ICC Women's World Cup Qualifiers, 2007-08 ICC World Twenty20 India and South Africa in Ireland, 2007 India in Australia 2007-08 India in Bangladesh, 2007 India in England, 2007 India in Pakistan 2005-06 India in South Africa 2006-07 India in West Indies 2006 Indian Premier League Kumar Sangakkara diary Quadrangular series, Ireland, 2007 Sri Lanka tri-series 2006 Under-19 World Cup World Cricket League
Recent Posts
Hectic and surreal English interests Momentum is over-rated The aftermath of The Slap Indian Foreign Legion? Slapgate - the IPL's first controversy Warne, a pocketful of sunshine Storm in the cheering corner Random thoughts from the first leg Expect the unexpected
Archives
May 2008April 2008March 2008February 2008January 2008December 2007November 2007September 2007August 2007July 2007June 2007May 2007March 2007February 2007January 2007December 2006November 2006October 2006September 2006August 2006July 2006June 2006May 2006March 2006February 2006January 2006
cricket links
The Guardian The Daily Telegraph The Times The Independent The Age Sydney Morning Herald The Australian NZ Herald SuperSport BBC Rediff
Web Feeds
© Cricinfo 2007