cricinfo.com About cricinfoblogs
Beyond The Blues Beyond The Test World Different Strokes From the Editor Girls Aloud Iain O'Brien Inbox
It Figures Pak Spin Shot Selection The Buzz The Confectionery Stall The Surfer Tour Diaries

Cricinfo Blogs Home

« Australia's early blows fail to connect | | Bigotry at silly point »

The Oval debacle

Posted on 08/21/2006 in Pakistan in England





© The Daily Telegraph
The decision of Darrell Hair and Billy Doctrove to award England victory at The Oval has created a massive reaction.

Ted Corbett, writing in The Hindu, tries to track where it all began:

The whole affair began, according to tales sweeping the Oval ground, when an England and Wales Cricket Board official went to the umpires' dressing room in the morning and asked them to watch out for ball tampering by the Pakistan players.

Geoffrey Boycott, writing in The Daily Telegraph describes the events as “farcical and reflected little credit on the England and Wales Cricket Board or the International Cricket Council”.

The ICC must be blind or stupid not to have realised that there is history between Darrell Hair, the umpire who accused them of changing the nature of the ball, and Pakistan. There were mutterings after the Headingley Test that Pakistan didn't like Hair's attitude.

Mihir Bose, cricket historian, feels the attack on Inzy's 'izzat' (honour) was the final straw.

Inzamam is one of those Pakistanis who passionately believes that a man can lose everything he has, including his life - but not his izzat. For him, the manner in which Hair took the decision as much as the decision itself meant that Inzamam's personal izzat, and that of his beloved Pakistan, had been besmirched.

Derek Pringle, Daily Telegraph's cricket correspondent, says pride, principle and prejudice replaced runs, wickets and catches.

"Everyone who follows the game, and has its interests at heart, needs a full explanation now, not least from the umpires and match referee," writes Mike Selvey in The Guardian.

In the same paper Lawrence Booth writes how Hair’s future is in doubt.

Simon Barnes writes in The Times “a small judgment about a small infringement of the laws created a day of outrage, distress and fury”.

Pakistan were not accused of ball-tampering yesterday. They were judged and found guilty by the umpire, Darrell Hair, as they sought to halt England’s second-innings resurgence. This is a profoundly serious business in cricketing terms. It is not like calling a woman a tease. It is like calling her a whore. Well, there are women who are whores, but you’d better be bloody sure of your facts before making the accusation.

Ian Botham, writing in the Daily Mirror, blames ICC for the chaos that enveloped The Oval.


Kamran Abbasi, writing in the Dawn, the Pakistan daily, writes that Hair has a track record of poor decisions and sparking controversy in matches involving Asian teams and feels that Pakistan would have been as mightily offended if the umpire involved had not been Hair. .

The Sun's John Etheridge writes on how an 18-stone Aussie called Darrell Hair trampled his feet all over the name of cricket with an astonishing display of pig-headedness.

James Lawton says in The Independenta Test match died at the Oval yesterday for a lack of trust between those who play cricket and those who administer it”.

The Telegraph, the Kolkata-based daily, tracks Sky Sports’ live coverage during the choatic unfolding of the events and records what the star commentators had to say. Click here to read.

Cricinfo’s coverage starts here.

 
Feedback Feedback

Categories
2009 English domestic season (4) American Premier League (1) Ashes (327) Australia in India 2008-09 (101) Australia in New Zealand 2009-10 (1) Australia in South Africa 2008-09 (14) Australian cricket (829) Ball tampering (2) Bangladesh cricket (27) Betting/Corruption (1) Bob Woolmer (8) Books (7) Bowling actions (3) Captaincy (1) Champions Trophy (55) Champions Twenty20 League (16) Charity (4) Commentary (66) Compaq Cup (1) Corruption (2) Cricinfo (3) Cricket (24) Cricket and war (1) Cricket books (8) DLF Cup (2) Drugs (2) England in India 2008-09 (66) England in South Africa 2009-10 (67) England in West Indies 2008-09 (73) English cricket (831) Falkland Islands (1) France (1) ICC (81) ICC Under-19 World Cup (5) ICC World Twenty20 (58) ICC anti-doping policy (10) India in Australia, 2007-08 (65) India in New Zealand, 2008-09 (34) India in Pakistan 2008-09 (1) India in Sri Lanka 2008 (18) India in Sri Lanka 2008-09 (2) Indian Cricket League (27) Indian Premier League (216) Indian cricket (637) Interviews (6) Irish cricket (4) Kenyan cricket (2) Miscellaneous (207) Neutral venues (1) New Zealand cricket (276) New Zealand in Australia 2009 (4) New Zealand in Sri Lanka 2009 (4) Obituaries (15) Offbeat (133) Olympics (1) One-day cricket (11) Pakistan cricket (134) Pakistan in Australia 2009-10 (13) Pakistan in England (56) Pakistan in Sri Lanka 2009 (1) Pitches (3) Racism (1) Security concerns (19) Shootout in Lahore (10) Sourav Ganguly (1) South Africa in Australia 2008-09 (36) South Africa in England 2008 (49) South African cricket (139) Sri Lankan cricket (89) Stanford 20/20 for 20 (24) Stats (3) T20 Canada (1) Technology (19) Television (25) Test Championship (2) Test cricket (1) Test rankings (4) The Delhi crisis (1) The Stanford saga (6) Twenty20 (63) UAE cricket (1) Umpires (50) Under-19 World Cup (1) United States of America (2) West Indies cricket (129) West Indies in Australia 2009-10 (6) West Indies in England 2009 (14) West Indies in New Zealand, 2008-09 (8) Women's cricket (27) World Cup 2007 (133) Year-end reviews (3) Zimbabwe cricket (47)
Recent Posts
'They must receive the accolades, not me' If only it were Imran Little help for New Zealand's selectors Loyal cricketing servants XI Nannes: The international man of mystery Hollow day proves game needs a rethink The power of 19 2011 World Cup not beyond New Zealand Siddle will bounce back from fast bowler’s curse Confusion in New Zealand
Archives
February 2010January 2010December 2009November 2009October 2009September 2009August 2009July 2009June 2009May 2009April 2009March 2009February 2009January 2009December 2008November 2008October 2008September 2008August 2008July 2008June 2008May 2008April 2008March 2008February 2008January 2008December 2007November 2007October 2007September 2007August 2007July 2007June 2007May 2007April 2007March 2007February 2007January 2007December 2006November 2006October 2006September 2006August 2006July 2006June 2006May 2006April 2006March 2006February 2006January 2006December 2005November 2005October 2005September 2005
RSS Feeds RSS Feed
© Cricinfo 2009
website stats