Cricinfo Blogs
cricinfo.com About cricinfoblogs
Alternate Reality Beyond The Blues Beyond The Test World Different Strokes Fantasy Post First Class, First Person Girls Aloud    Inbox   
It Figures Long Stop Pak Spin Rob's Lobs The Buzz The Surfer Tour Diaries Tour of Duty

Cricinfo Blogs Home

« Warne remains at his entertaining best | | And on the seventh day... »

September 5, 2007

Posted by Rob Steen on 09/05/2007

Five jewels for Wisden





Ian Bell has been the best batsman on view in the one-day series against India © Getty Images
Editing Wisden Cricketers’ Almanack may be the plummest job in cricket journalism but that doesn’t mean the man on the throne doesn’t need a helping hand. (And yes, it’s always the hairier of the species: after all, now that Moira Cameron has become the Tower of London’s first female beefeater, the post remains one of this green and sometimes pleasant land’s few unstormable male bastions.)

Scyld Berry, arguably the most broad-spectrumed, lateral-thinking writer ever to grace a cricket pressbox, is acting as locum for the yellow bible’s 2008 edition as Matthew Engel takes a richly-earned sabbatical. As ever, his trickiest task will be to choose his Five Cricketers of the Year, an honour recently restored to its original confines – prime consideration is given to those summering in England. In other words, before you start shouting at me for bypassing Stuart Clark, Yousuf Youhana and Kumar Sangakkara, exploits overseas count for little or nowt. In the interests of brotherhood and posterity, therefore, I would like to take this opportunity to proffer some fairly humble suggestions. And yes, I know the season isn’t quite over, but on the basis that achievements over the last three weeks of a five-and-a-half-month campaign can, and should, only count for so much, that should not be a deterrent.

First, though, a rider. The rules have always precluded the nomination of any previous Cricketer of the Year, which is an especial pity this year. The star county turns, after all, have been the oldies – Andy Caddick, Ottis Gibson, Mark Ramprakash and Mushtaq Ahmed, of whom only Gibson has not hitherto been a recipient. So with that in mind, the nominees are…

Ian Bell

He ebbed and flowed in the Tests, relegated to No.6 and even 7 by his returning captain and assorted nightwatchmen, but in the one-day series against India, to date at least, he has been the best batsman on view. Given the stiffness of the competition, numbering as it does Messrs Collingwood, Dhoni, Dravid, Pietersen and Tendulkar, this should on no account be sniffed at. Finally beginning to assert and impose, he is surely England’s long-term five-day No.3, as frequently hinted at during the Ashes series. One blessing arising from Andrew Strauss’s decline is that it may persuade Michael Vaughan to open with Alastair Cook in Sri Lanka. Either way, that sheepish, “Do I really belong?” smile has been usurped by the beginnings of a fiendishly sadistic grin.

Shivarine Chanderpaul

“He should be extra careful and avoid getting excited while playing, else, it may dampen his game.” So says astrologer Bejan Daruwalla’s Tarot card reading for Guyana’s gutsiest. Which tells you almost all you need to know about astrologers. The only thing that appears to excite Chanderpaul the Test batsman is occupying creases for days on end and annoying purists and opposition alike. All but left in the lurch by Brian Lara’s retirement, Ramnaresh Sarwan’s injury and Chris Gayle’s frippery, he rose heroically to the occasion: getting him out has been the summer’s stiffest ask. A pity he has been deemed unsuitable captaincy material: nobody in this dark decade for Caribbean cricket, not even dear Brian, has done more to lead by example.

Ottis Gibson

Speaking of which… Given that coaching acumen and those Bajan roots, it seems barely credible that the West Indies have seen fit to overlook his services in some capacity or other. Not that Durham are complaining: his enduring potency as a seamer brought the most tenderfooted first-class county their first piece of silverware, and may yet bring home their first rasher of Championship bacon. A decisive burst in the Friends Provident final and the first 10-for in county cricket since 1994 comprised the icing on a resplendent cake.

Chris Schofield

On figures alone, Danish Kaneria should win my vote, but why not reward persistence, especially when it comes packaged in such inspiringly Disneyfied wrapping? It would, admittedly, be far too insular to describe the Surrey leggie’s revival as the comeback of the sporting summer: Rick Ankiel of the St Louis Cardinals, a highly-touted pitcher who lost his nerve a few years back after an horrendous playoff game, has lately been reborn as a home-run hitter, a conversion akin to Glenn McGrath learning how to mash middle-order hundreds. Still, the erstwhile Great White Hope of English spin has worked untold wonders in reigniting a career that could yet be, if not as great as hoped and hyped, then certainly a great deal better than most feared after his rapid decline. Hand injury permitting, the Twenty20 world championship - his mother burst into tears of relief when his name was announced in England’s preliminary squad - may confirm the unlikeliest second coming since the Mullet.

Zaheer Khan

The pitches may be subterranean much of the time, but a summer at Worcestershire need not be a total waste. A late replacement for Nathan Bracken, India’s erratic spearhead took 78 Championship wickets in 2006, sussing out the terrain and returning to torment England’s batsmen as no left-arm quick has done since Wasim Akram. Of his 18 wickets in the Pataudi Trophy series, 12 were plucked from the top six in the first two Tests, five of them in that rubber-resolving second innings at Trent Bridge. Nobody, one rather suspects, will ever offer him jellybeans again.

Go to Comments

Comments

Posted by: Merlin on 09/05/2007

4 out of 5. Whilst I think no praise is too high for Schofield's determination and re-emergence, I'm not sure he's done enough yet to be "Cricketer of the Year". Not sure who to put in his place mind

Posted by: john boon on 09/05/2007

as much as i dislike him for what he did in the ashes, stuart clark surely deserves a nomination.

Posted by: Jamie Dowling on 09/05/2007

I can't really disagree with any of these choices. Ian Bell has looked fantastic when playing at his best, his driving through the offside is, for me, better than Michael Vaughan.

Chanders has had masses written about him this summer by people far better qualified than I to rate him. He's the hard working guts of the West Indian team and deserves all the credit he gets and more besides for that.

Ottis is as deserving as anyone. His smile, languidness and approach are what cricket is really about - playing hard but enjoying it too. First ball 6 into the Taveners stand in the FP final says something about the man. And his 10-for put a huge smile on my face as I read the updated scorecards at work.

Chris Schofield - mistreated by England (ie Duncan Fletcher)? Perhaps. Mistreated by Lancashire? A tribunal seemed to think so. From reports he's worked damned hard to get back into 1st class cricket and his Twenty20 selection is on merit for that hard work. Include him to show that hard work does have its rewards.

Zaheer's performance in the tests was most enjoyable and gratifying when things started getting schoolboy silly with jelly bean japes. Swing is king for Zaheer and who'd have thought India's swing bowlers would best ours this summer?

But we're not Scyld Berry. I'll bet his selections will have been thought through with the thoroughness we've come to expect from him. Damn sure they'll be thought provoking.

Posted by: swapnil shah on 09/05/2007

I would say that Dinesh Karthik deserves a spot although I am sure he will come back in later years and have a bigger impact on a Eng-Ind series than he did this year.

Posted by: Nishad Jayasundara on 09/05/2007

Is Wisden cricketer of the year only for those who leave a memorable impact against England. If not, there is that man Lasith Malinga, at least a nomination for his hair...!

Posted by: Jack Wass on 09/06/2007

One can't disagree with your assessment of Chanderpaul as the toughest wicket to prise out of the summer, but why he's not captain? I was under the impression that was because he gave it up...

Posted by: Pete on 09/06/2007

I think Ryan Sidebottom should be one of the 5 for his amazing return to England colours, probably in place of Schofield.

Posted by: Mohamed Rahaman on 09/08/2007

Seems like Mr. Rick Ankiel of St. Louis Cardinals had some help recovering after all... Something called HGH. Landis, Armstrong, Bonds, Palmiero, Sean Merriman (San Diego Chargers) and the list goes on and on and not to mention all the American track & field athletes who have used but just never got caught. It's all about steroids.
I know that this information about Mr. Ankiel was not available when this article was written, but I am not too crazy for baseball references from cricket writers or commentators. Perhaps I will change my mind when I hear a baseball commentator or writer say something like "that pitch was like a googley" or it's a "stickey wicket out there".

  Post your comment
Posting Guidelines
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left

Rob Steen is a sportswriter and senior lecturer in sports journalism at the University of Brighton whose books include biographies of Desmond Haynes and David Gower (1995 Cricket Society Literary Award winner) and 500-1 - The Miracle of Headingley '81. His 2004 investigation for The Wisden Cricketer, Whatever Happened to the Black Cricketer?, won the EU Journalism Award For diversity, against discrimination. Sports Journalism -­ A Multimedia Primer, his latest offering, will be published by Routledge in August.
Categories
English cricketIPLSouth African cricketStanford Super Series
Recent Posts
All hail Lord SnootyA one-sided coinPlay it again, AllenIn search of wisdomA tide in sore need of turningThe sweet taste of humble pieChampioning the causeThe pain of DwayneOf winners and nice guysStop shopping at Tresco
Archives
November 2008October 2008September 2008August 2008July 2008June 2008May 2008April 2008March 2008February 2008January 2008December 2007November 2007October 2007September 2007August 2007July 2007June 2007
RSS Feeds Web Feeds
© Cricinfo 2008