When you commit to watching the IPL, you resign yourself to spending several weeks in the company of a rag-tag bunch of presenters, pundits and media personalities. Over the course of the tournament, these people will become as familiar to you as your own family and in many cases, just as annoying. And none more so than Setanta’s hand-picked studio guests.
For the opening day, they had drafted in noted former slogger and radio persona Ronnie Irani as their IPL in-studio instant analyser. His mission: to give us the inside track, to be our mole, our secret agent; letting us in on what really goes on behind the scenes and explaining the nuances of the wonderful game to the uninitiated.
And we learnt many things on that first day. We discovered, for instance, that Kevin Pietersen and Shane Warne have something of a rivalry. Yes it’s true and apparently that meant that both of them were really keen to win their first game. We also learnt that playing in the IPL is a great opportunity; that Tendulkar is a really good batsman and that Freddie will be a bit disappointed with his opening day performance.
All too soon, our Irani time was over. I was keen to be further enlightened and so when I discovered that Sunday’s studio guest was to be one Darren Gough, my cup ranneth over. A fine bowler, a belligerent blade swinger and a nifty mover in the ballroom, he was sure to embroider the fine cloth of the day’s entertainment with the golden thread of insight.
It is difficult to sum up the full effect of an afternoon with Goughie, but I will give you just a flavour. Early on, he ruffled a few feathers by tipping everyone’s favourite losers the Kings XI Punjab. Hello, I thought, this is more like it. Controversy. A maverick opinion. Excited, the studio presenter pressed him further. What was it about the Kings XI that made him pick them out as tournament winners? Turned out that Goughie liked Brett Lee, he liked the boy Sreesanth and he was enamoured of Marsh and Hopes.
It matters not that one of them will miss the whole tournament and the other three will be unavailable until the second half. Their influence will be felt strongly in their absence. Unfortunately, on this occasion, the phantom Lee, the invisible Sreesanth and the cardboard cut-outs of Hopes and Marsh proved unable to overcome the Delhi Daredevils and Punjab received a predictable and not entirely unenjoyable spanking.
Of course, Yuvraj had other players available, such as the talented young Indian batsman Kamran Goel who blazed away so effectively at the top of the order. What, the studio presenter wondered, did Goughie think of him? “To be honest,” opined the Dazzler, “I’ve never heard of him.” Eat your heart out, Nasser Hussain.
Now you may be thinking that this is just a cheap shot at the expense of a great player. And you’d be right. But I would offer one mitigating plea in my defence. If the only requirement for obtaining a seat in a Setanta studio is the capacity to state the bleeding obvious, or to look down a list of names and spot the good players, then I’m sure there are many cricket fans out there who would happily do the job for a fraction of the fee earned by Mr Irani or Mr Gough. Heck, I’d do it for nothing.
Of course, the task facing the studio analyser is as nothing compared to the job of match commentator, for whom the IPL represents the ultimate challenge. In a Test match, they are allowed to wax lyrical, to speculate, to fall asleep, even to snore occasionally. There is no such respite for the average IPL microphone jockey. They have a script to stick to and at regular intervals, prodded by the muzzles of the rifles wielded by the Lalit Modi Revenue Maximisation Squad, must correctly acknowledge certain benevolent corporate bodies.
This coercion has taken its toll on the minds of those held captive in the commentary booth. Sunil Gavaskar is no longer able to screw in a light bulb without declaring it a Citi moment of success. Mark Nicholas involuntarily greets the popping of his toaster with the words, “DLF Maximum!” And Ravi Shastri wakes up screaming in the middle of the night from a dream in which he forgot to read out the list of tournament sponsors.
Perhaps the cruellest ordeal of all for these prisoners is that they are not allowed to tell the truth about a particularly hideous piece of merchandise that regularly appears on our screens. No, not Kevin Pietersen; I’m referring to the IPL Trophy.
When I first saw it, I assumed it was a homage to the IPL prepared by some Cape Town schoolchildren using plastic cups, pipe cleaners and glitter pens. But no, it is the reward for winning the richest tournament in cricket. Apparently it is covered in diamonds. Rarely can so much money have been spent to such little effect (and I include Surrey’s signing of Shoaib Akhtar).
And yet, presented with an image of this monstrosity, Robin Jackman is not allowed to point out that it is the tackiest piece of decoration you are likely to see outside of David Beckham’s third living room. Nor can Greg Blewett politely suggest that it might have been better if they’d simply piled the diamonds up on a silver plate. Instead, they must show due deference and declare it a stunning piece of trophyware.
Truly, we should feel their pain and give thanks that they have sacrificed their commentating careers for the good of the IPL.
all i can say is "truth told in a hillarious manner"
Posted by: Prashant Kondi at April 22, 2009 5:00 AM
hahaha.. well written.. loved the sarcasm @ the commentators and studio "analysts".. keep them comin..
Posted by: dan at April 22, 2009 5:29 AM
nice post...
Posted by: Kris_mg at April 22, 2009 5:56 AM
Man.. You are awesome..and soo truthfull. That was the tackiest piece of ornament I have seen and I couldn't believe it was really the IPL trophy. What was even more funny was the way commentators were waxing eloquent over this "beautifull piece of art".. OOOhh... The situation in India is also bad.. Hee we have the match aired in SONY SetMax channel with hindi commentary and man.. it soo boring that even with all the hard hitting of a T20 match they lull you to sleep.. and the analysis and presentation in between, less said about it the better.. With all the money they should really think of hiring some professionals to do the job of match analysis..
Posted by: Looch at April 22, 2009 6:46 AM
A great post, humour and honesty all in the one article!
Posted by: vishal at April 22, 2009 7:08 AM
No, I don't quite agree with the comments posted above.There is no trace of sarcasm all through the piece.He has just stated the bleeding obvious whilst expecting a modicum of the same from the people who are paid to enlighten us.
"They have a script to stick to and at regular intervals, prodded by the muzzles of the rifles wielded by the Lalit Modi Revenue Maximisation Squad, must correctly acknowledge certain benevolent corporate bodies."
I hope the commentators( greats and respectable players in their playing days ) are one day embarrassed at selling themselves so cheap!
Posted by: mil1069 at April 22, 2009 8:14 AM
Dear Dear,
Is this a true view of old blighty or are these sour grapes for not been able to organise such a grand event on your own turf for the failure of Stanford project?
Well give atleast credit to IPL because of which your old blighty's own sons like Flinty and co., Mark Nicolas and co. and may be lots of poms working in various capacities for IPL are earning decent money in today's weak global economic scenario.
I do agree that this trophy will be in David beckham's 3rd living room. it is but natural since first two living rooms must be full of Victoria Adams or Rebecca Loos's stilleto's, minks and etc.
Regards,
mil1069
Posted by: pvk007 at April 22, 2009 9:18 AM
Brilliant piece... It's a shame that you covered Setanta and not India's primary (read only) broadcaster. Oh, the pain... I have taken to watching the games on mute. Its as much as fun as watching a silent movie, but spares my heart and hair.
Posted by: Sunil, UK at April 22, 2009 9:53 AM
The trophy and presenters are equally unimpressive. However, let me point out the gold /diamond 'artpeice' is (in case our non-Indian friends dont know) is the map of India. Over the top definitely, but the black shoe box stuck at the back is even worse. However, enough cynicism, let us at least try to enjoy the cricket.
Posted by: Gautam at April 22, 2009 10:57 AM
Sony has further piled on the Indian audience' misery by inflicting the likes of Mandira Bedi upon us. Also a daily one hour preview showing highlights of the previous matches ensures that the only words we hear are DLF maximum, Citi moment of success etc. As for the trophy i am told Modi got it designed during his college days in US by a belly dancer in Las Vegas.
Posted by: Chidananda at April 22, 2009 12:57 PM
The trophy embodies the tournament itself. An ostentatious,gaudy affair with lots of razzle-dazzle,but lacking in real beauty.
Posted by: ChooForTwentyChoo at April 22, 2009 1:32 PM
Setanta and Modi together have managed to showcase everything that is wrong with the dollarisation of cricket - without ANY help from Sandford! But they have missed a few tricks to REALLY 'bring on the tacky' for IPL, including: the Elvis Studio Powerplay (where commentators have to both dress and talk like Elvis during the traditionally slower 12-17th overs; promote Sponsor Name Bingo for viewers to play and win prizes (including full size plastic replicas of that fabulous IPL trophy for all our living rooms!); and introduce the fabulous new game 'Roadie Modi' where viewers at home can use their Sky buttons to play the role of Lalit Modi and ask other cricketing boards to make bids to stage the IPL on their home turf! Wow - I'm so excited, I just have to listen to some Mark Nicholas commentary to wind down!!
Posted by: Aditya at April 22, 2009 5:00 PM
You can imagine...I mean Mandira Bedi, as pretty as she is, knows nothing about cricket, and the Hindi commentary should be used to torture Guantanamo Bay detainees.
Posted by: Matt at April 22, 2009 6:44 PM
Dunno why it is that only thing a POM is good at is sarcasm!!! Funny piece but with all that you guys gotta start thinking about positive side of life than just being cynic at everything happening.
Posted by: Rodney at April 22, 2009 7:16 PM
Each time they cut back to the Setanta Studio the presenter says "in the studio Ronnie Irani". How pathetic are these so called experts. If Irani was as good as he makes himself out to be then why is he sitting in London and not wearing an IPL uniform and playing for one of the teams.
Posted by: Chris at April 22, 2009 7:47 PM
Glorious piece. I doubted, prior to watching the coverage of the opening day, that cricket broadcasting could plumb depths lower still than those trawled by Hussein and Botham. In the form of Irani, however, Setanta and the IPl do seem to have sumbled upon the utter nadir of commentary. One can only, confronted with such self-evident, laddish commentary, turn to messyrs Martin-Jenkins, Agnew, Marks, Selvey and Boycott in the TMS box. It is truly depressing that the mantle of Arlott, Johnson and Frindall is to be taken up and continued by ineducated, inarticulate "lads".
Incidentally,the IPL trophy scales hitherto unconquered peaks of vulgarity.
Posted by: RITS at April 22, 2009 7:54 PM
so true, hope someone in setanta sits up and takes notice. and who are the presenters?
Posted by: FlashAsh at April 22, 2009 10:42 PM
Dear Cricinfo
Great post!! Aussies can't seem to get sarcasm unless its sent via txt message or with instructions on the back!!
Oh and "Rodney" should know that Ronnie is sitting in a studio and not in IPL uniform because his bones gave out and forced his retirement from all forms of cricket!! Shame it can't be said of your fingers!! Just enjoy the tournament
Cheers
Posted by: Anabayan Kris at April 23, 2009 6:44 AM
Wow!
This is becoming reallllyyy boring! I could manage a laugh if i read one piece of sarcasm every hour. But cricinfo seems to have a policy to publish at least 1000 such pieces before the IPL ends. Its pathetic really... only to focus on what's bad.. too English if you ask me. Never mind that World T20 and IPL helped to spike interest in cricket again when World Cup 2007 debacle very nearly killed cricket in India.
Too bad cricinfo.. just another lackey for The Empire :(
Posted by: Andrew Hughes at April 23, 2009 8:29 AM
Thanks everyone for the kind words. I should point out that I am enjoying the IPL thus far, aside from having to hit mute when the Setanta studio guests come on. Indeed I would far rather be watching the IPL than following the snoozefest that is the County Championship or getting involved in the utterly tedious speculation about whether or Vaughan or Bell or A.N.Other will be in the England batting line-up.
Yet surely it is perfectly possible to enjoy something whilst poking a little gentle humour at it as well. Sarcasm is irony with a dash of bitterness and anger; irony used to wound or cut rather than to amuse. To the extent to which this piece is sarcastic, it has failed, since I have no wish to hurt anybody.
Posted by: John vdW at April 23, 2009 9:09 AM
The IPL is awesome, I'm loving it. But this piece of writing is absolutely fantastic - parody I think is the word - doesnt make the author a bad or ungrateful person - doesn't make the IPL a bad product. Seriously funny bit of writing, and none of it displays any ignorance. If anytg, it displays the exact opposite. Well done.
Posted by: aby Mathew at April 23, 2009 10:26 AM
Brilliant article, Just shows you what you can do if you have a great business model and plenty of money, You could buy everyone including tell them what to say. Commentators forced to say DLF & citi moments of crap. Nothing but cheap publicity stunts & gimmicks. Packer circus was something , but IPL is even more crap than that . By claiming they are giving livelihood to players is absolute crap.Only GOD knows the exact level of corruption, power politics, back stabbing & false promises these business corporates && Fimstars and mallayas and ambanis have done. half of India is struggling without proper housing and food.& these business corportas with political influence and banks money(which belong to public) eat up.
Posted by: Anabayan Kris at April 23, 2009 2:30 PM
Hey Andrew,
I'm sorry if i sounded bitter or tasteless... i suppose i could have enjoyed your article if i wasn't so mobbed by cricinfo's coverage of putting only the gaudy things on sight on the site. And the English media have been so pathetic. They don't seem to like anything that could make cricket stronger.... Pietersen, IPL, Great Exhibition to name a few. They seem to be so cynical of everything that it becomes very hard to appreciate really good humor.
Cheers!
Posted by: Harry Akkers at April 23, 2009 8:50 PM
Oh, so someone actually watches this tournament! Come on how many people can afford to dosh out more money on top of their Sky sports subscriptions.
I know very very few people who had seen anything of IPL. Its not the done thing around here. IPL made a mega mistake by handing this franchise to some pay-per-view channel. IPL will not take off in the UK like this,
Posted by: Gaurav Nayak at April 23, 2009 11:41 PM
Mindblowing, sir. Evocative to the full. One hopes that more articles will flow through from that expressive pen of yours. Setanta's commentary is puerile, and the less said about ronnie irani the better. Poor man's Scott Styris.
Posted by: Anton at April 24, 2009 12:53 AM
I like Greame Thorpe. He sopeaks fluenty with a clear voice and mostly talks good sense. He was part of Sky's in studio analyser. Nick Knight, who is also part of Sky's team, is also good.
Posted by: Moin at April 24, 2009 5:38 AM
Nice post. But there is one error, there is no one by the name 'Kamran' Goel...it is Karan Goel...may be the new sensation 'Kamran' khan was in author's mind :)
Posted by: Vijay at April 25, 2009 6:58 PM
Sarcasm is good for a change, but Cricinfo seems to dish out sarcasma for a good part of the entire meal. Much of it seems to stem from the IPL guidelines of selling photos by news agencies or whatever it is. With due respect, it seems the only thing the English is capable is being sarcastic. Remember, T20 is a format, which was invented by the English, but till the IPL, they never realised what potential it holds. Remember Lalit Modi created this multi million dollar event out of nothing no matter how much ever capitalistic this event may be or how irritating his speeces are. After the IPL, the English now wants their own EPL or P20, but still they are awaiting for the nod from the BCCI to release its players for the event. Remember, the IPL I one was great success without any of the players from England. Remember nothing is going to change by Tom and Dick spreading rumours about Harry while Harry is 1000 miles away and doing what he does, kicking butts. Grow up Guys.
Posted by: Prashant at April 25, 2009 8:36 PM
Hey Andrew-don`t mind the unkind words-maybe they are coming at you Courtsey of Mr Modi`s squad-I for one am njoying reading ur posts and am njoying a little bit of cricket that teh IPL manages to get in between the stratergic timeouts and notso stratergic weather/ad/dog /etc time outs
keep them coming
Posted by: Gaurav at April 30, 2009 12:54 PM
Huh!!! what ever people are making fortune out of it.
Posted by: Andrew Hughes at April 30, 2009 3:19 PM
Moin, well spotted. Whilst poking fun at Mr Gough for not knowing who he was, I really should have got his name right!
Posted by: female_cricket_fan at May 6, 2009 12:57 AM
great article!
and yes.. the trophy is hopeless
Post your comment
About this blog
'Inbox' will feature submissions from you with us playing gatekeeper as we do with the rest of the site. We will set no rules apart from
ensuring a certain quality that you have come to associate with Cricinfo. You may write on the aspects of the game that you
hold dear; about matters that rile you; about players, teams and trends; you may share your memories and views, and
you may so do so in 100 words or 500. The only tip we will give you is to repeat a line from
our style sheet: Brevity is not just the soul of wit, it is the heart of all writing.
Welcome. (Editor, Cricinfo)