Cricinfo Blogs
cricinfo.com About cricinfoblogs
Beyond The Blues Beyond The Test World Different Strokes From the Editor Girls Aloud Iain O'Brien Inbox
It Figures Pak Spin Shot Selection The Buzz The Confectionery Stall The Surfer Tour Diaries

Cricinfo Blogs Home
Inbox From our readers

« Saint KP | | Music to a cricket fan's ears »

Sachin v Gilly

Posted by Cricinfo - on 10/24/2008

From Bidwan Baruah, India

The "Monkeygate" affair is back in the news again. Of course now the media has some food on their plate till the next match begins. But what is the bigger picture? Why now? I know Gilchrist had written this quite some time back and his book is yet to be released, but why has this come to the press now?

Australia 1-0 down in the series, Sachin reaching the 12000 run mark, Indians booming with confidence, how about some mind games? And that too from the player regarded as the 'most honest', Gilly 'The Walker' to the one regarded as the 'most respected'. The mind games are not working for the Aussies this time whether it be Ponting telling that Zaheer that he had a 'rare' good match or insisting their so called spinners are bowling better then the Indian counterparts only to be contradicted by their camp later on with the coach Neilsen acknowledging Zaheer's awesome mastery over reverse swing and the performance of all the Indian bowlers.

Now, the million dollar question: Will Sachin respond like he did when 'Guru Greg' questioned his integrity? If he does, the war of words will escalate. And if he doesn't, the Aussies might say Sachin is guilty and so has not responded. In either case there is just one team that gains from of all this: No, not Australia or India. It's the Media.

 
Feedback Feedback
Comments Submit your piece >>

Posted by: Anjo at October 24, 2008 11:19 AM

If by media you mean Gilchrist's autobiography then you may be correct. A cheap marketing gimmick timed to perfection right in the middle of the next series, maybe but it might well affect sales in the subcontinent, if they were ever bothered by that. Maybe thats good, in recent times we've seen almost everyone remotely connected with a national team stoop to such tactics to get more publicity for their books, so its about time the general public responded by saying if you sell trash there will be few buyers. I'm not going to bring up monkeygate again, but as honest as Gilchrist appears to the general public he's admitted that nobody who played the game is a saint, so I'm not buying his version as gospel truth. It was a lot more than one person casually slipping a racial slur. (only if that did occur, of course :) )

Posted by: Kunal at October 24, 2008 1:38 PM

Nice one dude.. I lost all the respect I had for Gilchrist and his sportsmanship ..

Posted by: Ahsan Iqbal at October 25, 2008 9:47 AM

Whether what Gilchrist says is true or not is not my concern, however I'd like to argue how the Indians so proudly claimed they are not racist. For Harbhajan to slap Sreesanth in front of a packed stadium during and IPL game, says a lot about his character (or lack of). That display of unsportsmanship and disrespect towards a fellow countryman openly declares that the man has no respect for anyone else. He could have easily called Symonds a monkey and could have denied it with the same ease. Why should one believe him? actions speak louder than words. And then for BCCI to jump in and use the tour itself as hostage, the board and some Indian players convincingly prove; character is innate, Sachin has it, most of the rest do not. Harbhajan can say whatever to Gilchrist, Gilly showed character and respect on and off the field. That is quite a bit more than what Harbhajan has done.

Posted by: C Fernandes at October 25, 2008 11:55 PM

Well done Adam Gilchrist - "pot calling the kettle black" you did get batsman to return to the crease whenever you appealed and they were given out (and were actually not out) - great gamesmanship / very sporting.

You also did rebuke the Australian players or have had a lot to say about your team mate’s behaviour when they abused and carried on against opposition players (McGrath / Warne) - No you just laughed it off. Did you not defend your players whenever they were wrong by your silence? Whatever Sachin did he probably did to defend his player.

Sachin has always played the game fair and as a gentleman (so also you in probably 95% of the time).

Great for one to keep saying keep it all on the field and then when it suits, have a say in the autobiography. If a sub continent player made such statement about a revered Aussie player - Geez he would be absolutely media bashed & crucified by the Aussie cricket players - past and present. What am I talking about "

Posted by: redneck at October 27, 2008 6:25 AM

gilly has backed up his words off field with preformances on field! who else would walk in a world cup semi final? and after a sparkling career both preformance wise (on field) and with his media interviews and public behaviour (off field) and as a result he should be able to mention a thing or two about his observations and situations he had come accross through out his career and whats more should be believed as he has never done anyting for the public to doubt his word! Harbhajan on the other hand has never done anything to proove to the public that his word should be trusted! sachin was sticking up for a team mate and fair enough too but he did change his story and good on gilly for calling it how it is!!!

Posted by: fairdinkum at October 28, 2008 2:11 AM

Sachin is undoubtedly one of the greatest players to have played the game, but for bloggers to claim that he always plays fair ignores his conviction on cheating in a test match. It was a conviction based on video evidence and it was ball tampering. How do you reconcile the saintly image with this fact. If you then point to incidences involving Australian test cricketers then you prove Gilly's point - no international cricketer is a saint. All the Australian test team believe that Sachin changed his testimony in Monkeygate to protect his teammate and save face. You and I don't know whether he lied or not.

Posted by: Ultimateman at October 28, 2008 1:41 PM

Fairdinkum...i suggest you watch the video of the "so called" ball tampering well and tell me from which angle it looks like ball tampering. He is not an idiot to do it in plain sight if that was the case. And if that doesnt convince you still..get back to the basics or pick another sport...try ping pong..its less complicated. Get your facts right.

  Post your comment
Posting Guidelines >>
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left
About this blog
'Inbox' will feature submissions from you with us playing gatekeeper as we do with the rest of the site. We will set no rules apart from ensuring a certain quality that you have come to associate with Cricinfo. You may write on the aspects of the game that you hold dear; about matters that rile you; about players, teams and trends; you may share your memories and views, and you may so do so in 100 words or 500. The only tip we will give you is to repeat a line from our style sheet: Brevity is not just the soul of wit, it is the heart of all writing. Welcome. (Editor, Cricinfo)
Submit your piece >>
Categories
About American cricket Ashes Australian Cricket Bangla cricket Batting Bowling Cricket through the decades Cricket videogames Crowds English cricket Extras Fans Fielding IPL Indian cricket League cricket New Zealand cricket Pakistan cricket Pitches Rankings Rules Selection T20 World Cup Twenty20 Umpiring West Indies Cricket World cricket
Recent Posts
Making sense of strange omissions Cricket and generation Xbox Restructure the game around Twenty20 A cricketing renaissance Grandmasters of cricket Where are my slippers? The genesis of a cricket nut Mystery and Magic: Iverson, Ramadhin, Gleeson and Mendis Mystery of the missing wrist-spinners Finetuning D/L method for Twenty20s
Archives
November 2009October 2009September 2009August 2009July 2009June 2009May 2009April 2009March 2009February 2009January 2009December 2008November 2008October 2008September 2008August 2008
RSS Feeds RSS Feed
© Cricinfo 2009