Since the retirements of Shane Warne, Stuart MacGill and Brad Hogg, the search for the next Australian spinner has continued with little success. Cricket Australia are aware of the issue; indeed, they have recently appointed Shane Warne in a consultative role to discuss the art of spin bowling with the captains of the Australian States and to mentor young spin bowlers. It is far too early to pass any judgment on what this role will actually achieve, but it is clear that Cricket Australia are attempting to be productive.
This is evident in the fact that Daniel Cullen, Cullen Bailey, Daniel Doran, Beau Casson, Cameron white, Steven Smith, Stephen O'Keefe, Jon Holland and Aaron Heal have been invited to the Commonwealth Bank Centre of Excellence, which is run by Cricket Australia and the Australian institute of Sport, in the hope that one or more of the invitees would go back to their states with the armoury capable of allowing them to succeed. The Australian selectors briefly considered Daniel Cullen and Cullen Bailey sufficiently promising to confer upon them Cricket Australia contracts and, in more recent times, they have given Beau Casson and Cameron White contracts. The unavoidable truth for most of the above players is that after attending the Centre of Excellence (which they were selected to attend on their promise or on their merits as spin bowlers), they have all regressed.
In Daniel Cullen's first year, he spun the ball prodigiously and was not afraid to use his variations. He took an amazing swag of wickets and was talked of as the next test spinner for Australia after MacGill and Warne. Cullen Bailey aggressively flighted the ball and attacked - looking always for wickets. After receiving their respective contracts and attending the Centre of Excellence, however, the two Cullen (s) lost their way. Cullen Bailey was reduced to bowling in a net, with a rope tied half way down from one side to the other, so he could find the flight that had deserted him. Same too Daniel Doran, who leapt on to the first class scene, spinning the ball and claiming wickets like his hero, Shane Warne. After attending the Centre of Excellence and enduring the ignorance of Jimmy Maher (his Queensland captain), he also faded in the reckoning. Although Beau Casson has now been picked for Australia, performing adequately in the West Indies, his career stalled terribly after attending the academy. He was unable to gain a place in the New South Wales side and was forced to change his action.
In Ashley Mallett's excellent biography of Clarrie Grimmett, the wizardly leg spinner that played for Australian in the 1920's and 1930's, he describes how important Grimmett and his bowling partner, the fiery Bill 'Tiger' O'reilly, considered developing one's own style of bowling. The commentator Kerry O'Keeffe tells of the time he saw Cameron White play cricket as a teenager and being able to spin the ball the way in which he wanted - a skill which O'keeffe believes is less evident for Cameron White in present time. The question is, therefore, are the coaches tinkering excessively with the techniques of the young spinners entrusted into their care? Is this the reason Australia fails to produce bowlers like Muttiah Muralitharan or Ajantha Mendis, great bowlers but who possess a curious technique? Would Clarrie Grimmett be instructed not to keep his arm so low, or tiger O'Reilly told not to bowl so fast if they were beginning to spin today? I hope not, but I have my doubts.
An intriguing point, and a good example using Ajantha and Murali. The spins stocks have really dried and it possibly could be due to over coaching.
Clarrie and Tiger would know all about coaching, hell Mailey told Tiger he wouldn't be a successful cricketer with his grip, but it goes to show you coaches aren't always correct.
Of those bowlers mentioned, I actually thought Heal might be a more permanent prospect, but we'll wait and see next Sheffield Shield season (Good to say that name again)
Posted by: Josephus at September 5, 2008 5:29 AM
I found this a really interesting and well written discussion Michael. If one were to look back at the time when Shane Warne first arrived on the scene, as is oft mentioned, pace bowling dominated most attacks and spin bowling was typically seen as a defensive tactic. Warne had developed his own technique without undue pressure to conform to a particular style, nor to "be the next" great spinner. It is an interesting point to suggest that for all its positives, the Centre of Excellence has in fact stripped promising bowlers of what made them promising in the first place - individuality. I can understand why, the pressure to fill the void left by Warne is significant. I can't help but feel sorry for Hogg and MacGill who constantly had the spectre of Warne's legacy hanging over them.
Perhaps a spell without a dedicated First XI spinner would allow space for a new talent to emerge from a natural process rather than a cookie cutter approach.
Posted by: Logan Stevenson at January 16, 2009 9:38 AM
seriously, you guys need to get into your thick heads that off spinners arent the solution, name one off spinner that is sucessful in the australian domestic cricket league, nathan hauritz has an average of over 45, aaron heal has an average of over 40, daniel cullen have an average of over 34, and jason krejza has an average of over 50 as well, so get into your thick heads and stop thinking that those bowlers have potential because they dont their all shit.
Post your comment
About this blog
'Inbox' will feature submissions from you with us playing gatekeeper as we do with the rest of the site. We will set no rules apart from
ensuring a certain quality that you have come to associate with Cricinfo. You may write on the aspects of the game that you
hold dear; about matters that rile you; about players, teams and trends; you may share your memories and views, and
you may so do so in 100 words or 500. The only tip we will give you is to repeat a line from
our style sheet: Brevity is not just the soul of wit, it is the heart of all writing.
Welcome. (Editor, Cricinfo)
RSS Feed
