cricinfo.com About cricinfoblogs
Blogs home
First Class, First Person Blues Brothers Rob's Lobs Tour Diaries Pak Spin Girls Aloud
Beyond The Test World On The Circuit What's New The Surfer It Figures Different Strokes

Cricinfo Blogs Home

« Nothing personal about it | | Character over cover drive »

January 25, 2008

Posted by Paras Mhambrey at 3:49 PM in

Ranji v Duleep





Players generally value the state team’s success more, but the standard of cricket in Duleep Trophy is better © Cricinfo Magazine

Everyone has a reason for playing cricket. Some play because their friends also play, some start with a single-minded focus of playing for the country. There are various steps one goes through before getting to that ultimate goal.

In Mumbai, cricket is big at junior levels: even playing for a school like Shardashram, where Sachin Tendulkar and Vinod Kambli played, is a matter of pride. Harris Shield, Giles Shield and other such tournaments are very competitive. After having played at those levels, one moves to age groups and then becomes one of the probables for Ranji Trophy. For a youngster that is a big thing, because that is one step below playing for the state, becoming a first-class cricketer.

I remember when I got picked for the Under-17 side, I saw it with a lot of pride. When I was handed the cap with the Mumbai Cricket Association (MCA) logo on it, it was a big thing for me. Every thing since then – collecting newspaper clippings, conversations with friends, et al – was a motivation for playing for Mumbai. With such a journey to playing for the state, one inevitably values every moment and success with the state team.

When a player starts playing for a state, he gets attached to particular venues too. For any cricketer in Mumbai, it is very special to play at the Wankhede, may it be the Ranji final or school cricket final or Times Shield tournament. I remember the first time I went to the Wankhede. Sachin was making his debut, and Achrekar sir [Ramakant Achrekar, my coach and Sachin’s] had picked us up and taken us to watch the game. The first thing that struck me was the lush green ground and I immediately told myself I wanted to play there.

When it comes to a team like Mumbai, there is a lot of history attached too. We have won the Ranji Trophy 37 times now, and whenever Mumbai fail to make it to the knockouts, it is considered a big failure. A Mumbai player knows great players have represented the team; there are stories and legends built around and that can be a source of both motivation and pressure.

**

Not all players get picked for the national team straight from the U-19s or state side. There are few like Parthiv Patel and Yuvraj Singh who do well at U-19 level and bypass the route. But others have to go through the system and this is where the Duleep Trophy comes in. It gives an opportunity to cricketers who have already done well for their state, but haven’t made it to the national side: there are three games if you make it to the final, someone like Parthiv who has scored 900-odd runs in the season gets a chance to take it to 1200-plus.

The timing this year is unfortunately not great. The squad for Australia has already been announced, but the players have to tell themselves there is a Test series coming up in March too. That said, this is better timing than the last two or three years when it used to be played before the Ranji Trophy. So the players would make it based on the previous season’s performance and wouldn’t necessarily carry on from where they had left then.

Different players from different teams come to play for a zone in Duleep Trophy. It is very difficult to adjust because the thinking and the attitude are different. For example, Mumbai players who have won Ranji 37 times think differently than some other teams. Then it is difficult to get all the different players to gel as a team for just two or three matches. Players are not comfortable in even sharing rooms. It may work for a senior, because the junior room-mate usually adjusts to his habits.

Duleep Trophy is an individualistic tournament, because – whether players accept it or not - everybody focuses on his own runs and wickets, being so close to selection. Playing for a state side comes with a sense of togetherness, with a lot of success and disappointment shared over a period of time. That bonding is missing in the zonal sides.

While getting used to players from different backgrounds is a must while playing for India – and just as difficult – but because one wants to play for India for as long as possible, he has to adjust. While playing Duleep Trophy, the attitude is to just somehow get through the two-three matches. Besides, while playing for a national side, when the whole world is watching, selfish players are exposed, something you can get away with while playing the Duleep Trophy. And then there is the pride of playing for a country. There is hardly any pride involved in representing your zone. There are different people from different states, some selfish, some hard to get along with.

While any success is cherished, players generally value the state team’s success more. But then again, the standard of cricket in Duleep Trophy is better as the best players from the country are playing there. Individual performances bring more satisfaction here. It still is a big thing to play Duleep Trophy: ask those who played a lot of Ranji Trophy, but couldn’t make it to Duleep Trophy. When one gets that opportunity, he should get over all the issues, and as a professional look at it as an opportunity and step closer to the goal.

Comments

Posted by: Juned at January 25, 2008 9:44 PM

Indeed Paras. Watching a Ranji trophy encounter is more fun than a Duleep trophy match. In fact, I would rate it higher than international cricket - as far as spectator participation and enjoyment is concerned.
Juned

Posted by: subhajit dasgupta at January 27, 2008 8:44 AM

Nice analysis, of course you are one of the most experienced in domestic circuit. In addition to your point, Duleep Trophy also helps the players in a team like Bengal, which was relegated from Super League, in spite of having a couple of players who are front liners to get into national time. While they won't get a chance now to show their mettle in the marathon Ranji trophy, Duleep Trophy is their only bet. Every system has their own pros and cons. Playing for zones, of course, as you mentioned is not as motivational as playing for your state. However, it's quite obvious in Indian Cricket, individualism is prevalent over the team. It owes quite a bit to the domestic cricket system, as you mentioned about players being selfish while playing for their zones. While it's not an easy problem to solve, but at least we know the problem. You might be a good one to propagate the Mumbai gharana in Indian cricket,like you've successfully done in Bengal in last season. You should think about it.

Posted by: Murtuza Sakerwala at January 27, 2008 1:21 PM

Paras, You are bang on target !!! it draws comparisons between the recent ICC Eleven versus Australia matches. Although the ICC side was far more superior side on paper it did'nt do as well. But having said that players need to develop the attitude of "Playing for the Team"
I think the Duleep trphy should have 2 extra teams the Ranji Trophy winner and the runner up.

Posted by: Samy at January 30, 2008 1:40 AM

I agree that the players seem to be playing for themselves in the Duleep trophy matches, which is being seen this year as well. The only teams which really show teamwork are the visiting teams, like the England Lions this year. The In this aspect, the Duleep trophy is similar to the Challenger series. Both competitions showcase the best talents in the Indian domestic scene, in Tests and one-dayers, and in both competitions the players play for national selection, and not for their teams.
I also think the timing for this year's Duleep trophy is correct. I hope they'll continue with the same schedule.

Posted by: Aditya Mookerjee at February 8, 2008 1:00 PM

It is great reading Paras Mhambrey's gems on Indian domestic cricket. The difference between The Mumbai Ranji Team, and the other Ranji Teams, is that The Mumbai team is an equal balance of individuals,and team men, while the other teams, depend on the team as a whole. That is the secret of Mumbai's success.

Posted by: manish at February 16, 2008 2:55 PM

I believe there should be a seperate team of mosttalented emerging players playing in ranji and duleep trophies so that they can be fast tracked to national side with the emphasis on fast bowlers;as indian fast bowlers against aussies have proved that to win matches abroad you need tearaway fast bowlers.With the likes of PANKAJSINGH, SUDEEP TYAGI AND PRADEEP SANGWAN on the waiting list; one should seriously consider 4 fast bowlers in INDIAN test team with 6 batsmen and 5 bowlers all the time.

Posted by: Aditya Mookerjee at February 17, 2008 12:08 PM

Please continue with the blog, on a fairly regular basis. This is one of the best blogs in the blogs section. The gentlemen who write the blogs, do it as it should be done.

  Post your comment
Posting Guidelines
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left
The Contributors

Sanjay Bangar has twice been a member of Ranji-winning Railways sides. He has also played 12 Tests and 15 ODIs for India, scoring one Test century and three half-centuries. This is his 15th first-class season.

Paras Mhambrey represented India in two Tests and three ODIs in the mid-nineties. He played for Mumbai, with whom he won the Ranji Trophy five times. He ended up with 284 first-class wickets from 91 matches. After retiring as a player, he coached Bengal to two Ranji finals in a row, and is coaching Baroda this season.
Ashwin
A tall Tamil Nadu offspinner who bowls with a high-arm action and is studying to be an engineer, R Ashwin has some uncanny similarities with S Venkataraghavan, but for the moment the comparison should end there. Ashwin (21) is taking his first steps in Ranji Trophy cricket. Already, though, he's had one strong season, leading the wickets tally for Tamil Nadu with 31 scalps at under 20.
For the diaries from the English domestic season, click here
Categories
Coaching (2) Experiences (1) Offbeat (2) Pre season (2)
Recent Posts
Character over cover drive Ranji v Duleep Nothing personal about it Devil is in the basics A cricketer's green room Not money for nothing No fringe benefits Rising after the fall Devil's playgrounds Adding agony to injury
Archives
February 2008January 2008December 2007November 2007October 2007
Web Feeds
© Cricinfo 2008