Blogs home
cricinfo.com About cricinfoblogs
Beyond The Blues Beyond The Test World Different Strokes From the Editor Girls Aloud Iain O'Brien Inbox
It Figures Pak Spin Shot Selection The Buzz The Confectionery Stall The Surfer Tour Diaries

Cricinfo Blogs Home

Beyond the Test world

« Canada's Ugandan star | | Democracy ... USACA style »

A long way from home

Posted on 01/30/2007 in Associates

It won't get many column inches in the mainstream cricket press, but the World Cricket League, which started in Nairobi yesterday and continues into next week, features the best of the rest, the six sides just under the ten Test-playing countries. For the two finalists, the rewards are bountiful - a place among the big boys in the inaugural Twenty20 World Championship in South Africa this September, along with $250,000. For countries used to surviving on annual handouts from the ICC of less than $200,000, that's big money.

With the exception of Bermuda, cricket is not a mainstream sport in any of the participants. And yet it survives, and in some instances thrives, despite the lack of attention and a relatively small number of enthusiasts.

The ICC, who do sterling work in supporting the game's second and third tiers, will rightly use the event to highlight that cricket is not just about the Indians and Australias of the world.

But there remains a nagging worry. The ICC boasts that the game is spreading across the world. But is that right? Is it taking root or is it surviving because more people from its hotbed - south-east Asia - are emigrating and keeping it alive for the duration of their careers?

In last year's Wisden Almanack, Matthew Engel raised this very issue. "Overwhelmingly, the game in non-traditional countries is played by expatriates, mostly South Asian. Journalists were kidded into believing that cricket was about to burst on China, on the basis of some warm comments by civil servants and a couple of coaching courses. I have seen not one shred of evidence to back this up. Are the kids playing with tapeballs on the streets of Shanghai? Are they heck!"

Take Canada. Of the squad in Nairobi at the moment, only three were born in the country, and two of those are over 35. Of the rest, five come from the Caribbean, four from India and each from Pakistan and Uganda. Whereas other Associates have a smattering of expats, Canada are utterly reliant on them.

Engel's comment attracted fierce criticism from those who either argued that England had more than their share of "imports" or that the game only spread in Asia, Africa, Australasia and the Caribbean through expats playing it in the first place.

The worry in some countries is that rather the game is not being continued by the second and third generations but is only being maintained by a steady flow of new immigrants
With regards to England, yes there have been quite a few non English-born players who have been picked for the side, but the game still has a massive stronghold in the country. The selection has been more about improving a solid side. And as for the ex-pats argument? Well, yes, but that's the crucial point. In the regions flagged the game was brought in but it was then embraced by the indigenous population and taken on as their own. This is exemplified no better than in CLR James's seminal work, Beyond A Boundary.

The worry in some countries - and again I come back to Canada - is that rather the game is not being continued by the second and third generations but is only being maintained by a steady flow of new immigrants. Canada's cricket heritage is rich but there is little sign that it has been built on. This is best underlined by the selection of former West Indies international Anderson Cummins. Forty years old and without a major match to his name since 1995-96, he made his debut in Mombasa last week. What message does that send out about the strength in depth of cricket in Canada?

It's not just Canada. Look at the USA, whose 2004 Champions Trophy side was a collection of ageing expats whose performances verged on the disgraceful. And the UAE, which is almost entirely dependant on its ex-pat workforce to keep the game alive.

Cricket's expansion should not be about filling teams with expats and expecting the locals to get excited about it. The only way cricket can gain a foothold in emerging countries is by actually getting the indigenous population to embrace the game, and two excellent examples where this is happening are Nepal and Uganda.



Anderson Cummins of Barbados, West Inbies ... and now Canada © Eddie Norfolk
Does it matter? Yes, because as the ICC looks to develop the game in as many places as possible, that means the financial cake has to be cut in ever thinner slices. The ICC needs to concentrate on a smaller number of countries where the chances of the game taking off. It is invidious that Uganda gets the same basic allowance as Belgium.

Cricket is in trouble in its traditional homes in Africa - Zimbabwe are hell-bent on destruction and South Africa seems to be falling out of love with the game. So efforts should be made in Uganda . And in Asia, which everyone accepts is the game's stronghold, a side like Nepal should really be given the leg up. It's about targeting rather than a scattergun approach.

In fairness to the ICC, they have a tough time and a lot of countries scrambling for a share of the spoils. It's about weeding out the weak and really looking to grow the game in areas where it has the best chance of taking root. It's an almost impossible ask. Look at the repeated failure of American Football to crack Europe ... and if football itself still battles for acceptance outside expats and schools in the USA, then the size of the ICC's task becomes clear.

Of course expats have a key role to play in expansion. But if the game is basically played by them, is it the game spreading or is it more about diehards clinging to the traditions of their homelands? In the UK there are baseball and American football sides, but they are almost all expat Americans and so few would seriously claim the games have taken hold. However, basketball and ice hockey are widely played by locals, boosted by some imported players and expats, and, crucially, the national side can stand on its own two feet. That's the difference.

 
Feedback Feedback

Comments

Posted by: Abs at February 10, 2007 5:09 AM

Very well said. I agree that expats making up a team is not goig to do any favours to the upbringing of the game. Here in Oman, the national team is a complete expatriate team. No wonder the Omanis have become disillusioned with this policy and have decided to quit cricket. There goes one country down the drain for the ICC.

Posted by: Berjo at June 26, 2007 1:55 PM

Interesting!

Isn't that what is happening in South Africa as well - a struggle to reach the indigenous people. Maybe quotas need to be introduced in other countries as well. What everybody realy hopes for is more and more Makahya Ntini's. But then the South African question rises: What about merit and national pride? The "

Posted by: Berjo at June 26, 2007 1:55 PM

Isn't that what is happening in South Africa as well - a struggle to reach the indigenous people. Maybe quotas need to be introduced in other countries as well. What everybody really hopes for is more and more Makahya Ntini's. But then the South African question rises: What about merit and national pride?

Posted by: zain at August 6, 2007 7:13 AM

hmmm if only the israeli idiots would let palestinians play im sure they would of qualified for the WC by now.

  Post your comment
Posting Guidelines
Name:
Email Address:
Comments:
characters left

By Martin Williamson and Will Luke
>> Email us with news and photos

RSS Feeds RSS feed
Recent Posts
Red faces as Uganda fire new CEO Ireland in hot pursuit of Full Member status Cricket the Maasai way Swamibapa favourites to take NPCA title Cricket Canada in crisis after loss of major sponsor Nigeria's exciting domestic calendar Namibia performance pleases coach North West African Championships postponed Jeroen Smits quits international cricket Swamibapa close in on NPCA title
Categories
ACC Trophy 2006 (6) ACC Trophy Challenge (4) ACC news (28) Afghanistan (58) Africa (7) Argentina (47) Associates (35) Australia (4) Austria (3) Bahamas (14) Bahrain (15) Belarus (1) Belgium (6) Belize (13) Bermuda (140) Botswana (19) Brazil (22) Brunei (8) Bulgaria (7) CSA Provincial Three-Day Challenge (1) Cameroon (5) Canada (101) Cayman Islands (24) Central American Championships (2) Chile (21) China (38) Costa Rica (7) Cricket Sixes (4) Croatia (8) Cuba (9) Cyprus (7) Czech Republic (1) Denmark (24) Dubai (9) East Asia-Pacific (8) El Salvador (7) England (2) Estonia (8) Europe (13) European Championships (6) European Indoor Championship (2) European Twenty20 (2) Falkland Islands (8) Fiji (30) Finland (9) France (14) Gambia (4) General (6) Germany (18) Ghana (9) Gibraltar (9) Greece (11) Guernsey (28) Hawaii (1) Hong Kong (42) Hungary (4) ICC (29) ICC Americas (23) ICC Intercontinental Cup (27) ICC World Cup Qualifiers (11) Indonesia (10) Iran (7) Ireland (84) Israel (19) Italy (21) Japan (24) Jersey (27) Kenya (147) Kuwait (9) Latvia (3) Lesotho (6) Malawi (3) Malaysia (27) Maldives (9) Mali (5) Malta (8) Mexico (13) Misc (3) Morocco (7) Mozambique (2) Namibia (34) Nepal (53) Netherlands (62) New Caledonia (4) Nigeria (27) North Korea (1) North West African Championships (1) Norway (18) Oman (21) Pacific (1) Pakistan (1) Panama (2) Papua New Guinea (29) Peru (11) Philippines (2) Phuket (4) Player diaries (8) Portugal (1) Prague (1) Qatar (12) Romania (1) Russia (7) Rwanda (20) Samoa (10) San Salvador (1) Saudi Arabia (11) Scotland (76) Serbia (1) Sierra Leone (17) Singapore (23) Slovakia (1) Slovenia (2) South American Championships (4) Spain (6) Suriname (5) Swaziland (10) Sweden (5) Switzerland (5) Tanzania (26) Thailand (23) Tonga (2) Turkey (4) Turks and Caicos Islands (6) UAE (42) USA (151) Uganda (89) Under-19s (17) Vanuatu (23) Vietnam (3) West Indies (6) Women's cricket (11) World Cricket League (76) World Cricket League Africa Division Three (1) World Cricket League Africas Division Three (1) World Cricket League Americas Division (15) World Cricket League Division 3 (2) World Cup (19) World Twenty20 (5) Zambia (4)
Archives
November 2009 (6)October 2009 (29)September 2009 (44)August 2009 (27)July 2009 (17)June 2009 (22)May 2009 (36)April 2009 (42)March 2009 (27)February 2009 (35)January 2009 (32)December 2008 (30)November 2008 (18)October 2008 (31)September 2008 (31)August 2008 (32)July 2008 (56)June 2008 (30)May 2008 (44)April 2008 (60)March 2008 (58)February 2008 (50)January 2008 (28)December 2007 (30)November 2007 (47)October 2007 (30)September 2007 (36)August 2007 (30)July 2007 (20)June 2007 (30)May 2007 (40)April 2007 (25)March 2007 (19)February 2007 (16)January 2007 (29)December 2006 (24)November 2006 (18)October 2006 (19)September 2006 (15)August 2006 (24)July 2006 (12)June 2006 (14)May 2006 (15)April 2006 (16)March 2006 (17)February 2006 (13)January 2006 (22)December 2005 (26)November 2005 (5)
© Cricinfo 2009
hit counter